USPTO Accountability Project
ACET's USPTO Accountability Project monitors the United States Patent and Trademark Office's compliance with applicable laws and regulations, with a particular focus on the agency's administration of the patent examination process and its obligations under the Paperwork Reduction Act.
Sensitive Applications Warning System ("SAWS")
The USPTO operated a secret program known as the Sensitive Applications Warning System (SAWS) from 1994 until March 2015. Under SAWS, the USPTO flagged certain patent applications for special handling — without notifying applicants — causing significant delays and, in many cases, the effective suppression of patent rights. ACET has pursued extensive FOIA litigation to expose the full scope of this program.
- Class Action under the Privacy Act. Paul Morinville, et al., v. USPTO, filed in June 2019 in the District of Columbia. Plaintiffs allege that the USPTO violated the Privacy Act by operating the secret SAWS. The USPTO moved to dismiss, a motion that the District Court denied in part on February 26, 2020.
- Class Action. eVideo Owners et al. v. U.S., Federal Court of Claims, Case No. 15-413-LKG. The suit names eVideo as the lead plaintiff in a class of (yet unknown) applicants whose patent applications were flagged under the SAWS. eVideo's video on-demand technology is covered by two patent applications that have been languishing in the USPTO for over 13 years. The suit seeks damages in USPTO fees and prosecution costs in applications after they were designated under the SAWS.
- 8-8-2018. The USPTO's cover-up of the secret SAWS.
- 7-18-2018. The SAWS disproportionately targeted individual and small entity inventors.
- Danny Huntington FOIA Requests and litigation. Comprehensive FOIA requests on the operation of the secret SAWS program since its inception in 1994 until its retirement in March 2015. Records include memos, directives, reports, emails, and SAWS guidance for examiners. Records show that all pending pre-GATT applications were flagged under the SAWS and that the Board of Appeals received SAWS information on appeals for applications flagged under the SAWS.
- February 2, 2017. ACET's second FOIA request from USPTO on derivation of paperwork burden estimates and on guidance for complying with OMB PRA reviews. [ FOIA Request No. F-17-112 ]
Related Laws & Regulations
- U.S. Patent Act
- USPTO Regulations
- USPTO MPEP
- Paperwork Reduction Act
- Freedom of Information Act
- Privacy Act
Other Parties' Relevant Actions
- Hyatt & AAET v. USPTO — On repealing MPEP 1207.04 blocking appeals to the Board